Chondrichthyes: Symmoriida

Carroll 1988); Coates & Sequeira 1998); Coates & Sequeira 2001) [CS01]; Janvier (1996); Zangerl 1981); Zangerl (1990). ATW021110.

Symmoriidae: Denaea, Cobelodus.

Characters: $ glossopharyngeal (IX) nerve exits through metotic fissure [CS01*]; dorsal surface of head with large denticles; $ only one dorsal reversal) [CS01*]; $ fin spine not composed of vascularised osteodentine (reversal) [CS01*]; $ fin spine does not precede dorsals (reversal) [CS01*]; $ caudal neural and supraneural spines not extended (reversal) [CS01*]; caudal fin usually symmetrical; $ procoracoid directed posteriorly [CS01*]; pectoral fins long; $ pelvic plate semicircular with anterolateral concavity [CS01*]; $ claspers with clawed terminus [CS01*].

Notes: "[CS01*]" indicates synapomorphies which were calculated from the data given in Coates & Sequeira (2001) using very different software (PHYLIP). Using the full Coates & Sequeira data set, this analysis yields a single most parsimonious tree identical to that found by the authors, but requires 3 more steps to reach it. The actual data used to generate these synapomorphies is slightly different and gives slightly different results.

Links: Untitled Japanese: teeth and some general anatomy).

Stethacanthidae:  Akmonistion, Stethacanthus.

Range: Carboniferous?

Phylogeny: Symmoriida :: Falcatidae + *.

Characters: narrow suborbital shelf [CS01]; amphistylic jaw suspension; $ "basicranium encloses Y-shaped canal enclosing division of dorsal into lateral aortae" [CS01]; hyomandibula short and crescent-shaped; $ whorls of fused, 3-cusped tooth families occur close to the level of the jaw articulation [CS01]; oropharynx lined with denticles; prominent caudal neural arches [CS01]; elaborate spine & brush structure on first dorsal [CS01]; $ anterior dorsal fin with triangular osteodentine spine, having distinct anterior shoulder and seated on baseplate containing globular calcified cartilage (see image at left) [CS01]; $ baseplate continuous with spine-brush complex [CS01]; posterior dorsal supported with radials and triangular cartilage [CS01]; caudal axis strongly upturned [CS01]; hypochordal lobe supported by long, distally splayed radials [CS01]; pectoral fins with long metapterygial whip [CS01]; scales with single crowns [CS01]; scales non-growing and restricted to discrete areas [CS01]; lateral line scales C-shaped [CS01]; strong sexual dimorphism, with highly modified anterior dorsal fin.

Note: Coates & Sequeira (2001) sometimes avoid calling the spine-brush complex a "dorsal fin." It is certainly unclear whether it is homologous to the dorsals of more conventional sharks. These authors are also rather unhappy with the odd results of their parsimony analysis and offer an alternative cladogram (the details of which are to be published), with "arguably more conventional" results. However, lacking the details of the alternative analysis, the pure parsimony results have been adopted here.

Image: (right) Akmonistion life reconstruction from [CS01]. Scale bar is 5 cm.

Links: Fish of the Bear Gulch; Stethacanthidae notes on sexual dimorphism by Prof. Lund);  Poecilodus jonesii - teeth).

Falcatidae: Falcatus.

Range: fr D.

Characters: $ loss of persistent metotic-occipital fissure (reversal) [CS01*]; $ glossopharyngeal (IXth) nerve does not exit through metotic fissure (reversal) [CS01*]; $ loss of hyoid articular area on posterolateral angle of otic capsule (reversal) [CS01*]; $ loss (reversal) of high aspect-ratio lunate heterocercal caudal fin (hypochordal radials short and/or segmented) [CS01*]; $ notochord terminates almost horizontally [CS01*]; $ pectoral articular surface stenobasal (reversal) [CS01*].

Links: elasmo.com, Wikipedia.

Notes: [1] "[CS01*]" indicates synapomorphies which were calculated from the data given in Coates & Sequeira (2001) using very different software (PHYLIP). Using the full Coates & Sequeira data set, this analysis yields a single most parsimonious tree identical to that found by the authors, but requires 3 more steps to reach it. The actual data used to generate these synapomorphies is slightly different and gives slightly different results. [2] All these reversals are not as unlikely as it may appear. They merely reflect the increasing consolidation of the palatoquadrate with the braincase and concommitant adaptation to a duraphagous, slow-moving, benthic habit -- a tendency finding its logical endpoint in the holocephalians. 011209.

Damocles: another stethacanthid-type shark with a particularly elaborate head-dress.

Phylogeny: Falcatidae : Holocephali + *.

Characters: pointed snout and crown of head and neck denticles, females naked and with shorter snout; orbits large; males with a large forwardly pointed dorsal spine; $ Loss of second dorsal fin (reversal) [CS01*]; nearly symmetrical high aspect ratio tail, denoting some cruising ability; $ pectoral fins elevated [CS01*]; pectoral fin with trailing metapterygial whip, otherwise thick and relatively stiff.

Links: Megaladon.html.

Notes: "[CS01*]" indicates apomorphies which were calculated from the data given in Coates & Sequeira (2001) using very different software (PHYLIP). Using the full Coates & Sequeira data set, this analysis yields a single most parsimonious tree identical to that found by the authors, but requires 3 more steps to reach it. The actual data used to generate these synapomorphies is slightly different and gives slightly different results. 020223.